The Cost of Ignoring Workplace Anxiety

Workplace anxiety doesn't always look obvious. Employees may continue performing, meeting deadlines, and showing up while quietly struggling with constant worry. This article explores the hidden costs of workplace anxiety, how it affects productivity and teams, and what organizations can do to create healthier working environments.

Once to me, a client, R., said that her work was "fine." She repeated herself three times at one time. Deadlines were fine. Her manager was OK. The new project didn't create any problems. After a couple more sessions, the truth was revealed: Most nights she was waking up at 4 a.m. with her heart pounding, rehearsing with her boss what she would say when she were there, and sending the same e-mail nine times, fearing that she'd sound stupid. For more than a year she didn't miss a single day of work. In her employment record she was a model employee. In fact, she was on a sugar high, and it wasn't known by anyone at her company.

This is how workplace anxiety typically manifests itself from the outside: No one notices it. It doesn't usually come as a big surprise mid-conference. It appears as if it's a little quieter than usual, takes a little longer to "speak up," and is a little more apt to say, "I'm fine," when they mean the opposite. Plus, it's quiet so it is easy to overlook. It's because of this that it costs so much money.

Anxiety is NOT just “being stressed”

Before we go further, I want to point out that the two are not synonymous, are used interchangeably and have different definitions. Stress is often related to a specific event, whether it's a deadline, a tough client, a major presentation and it usually subsides after the event. Anxiety is stickier. It's a way of continually feeling anxious, stressed and feeling dread that doesn't necessarily end once the trigger has passed. A person who suffers from stress at work may have a tight stomach in the morning, even when they're going to an empty Slack. The nervous system remains on the alert for an imminent danger which might not materialize.

It's important for employers, as stressed employee will generally get better with a little rest. A stressed-out worker, specifically one who has been stressed for several months, does not recuperate the same means. That's where the REAL cost begins to add up.

The expense that you see, and the much larger expense that you don't.

Most companies monitor absenteeism, which encompasses workers not showing up, workers who are late or miss deadlines. This is one of the numbers that is easily retrieved from HR software. But research has continually indicated that absenteeism is the lesser of the two problems. The larger, far more costly half is presenteeism, whereupon an employee comes to work, sits at his desk and does the job at a lower level than he can, but not because his abilities are limited, but because his mind is elsewhere. Presenteeism can be estimated to cost employers about ten times that of absenteeism because it goes unaddressed, it is invisible.

Perhaps this is an understatement. Depression and anxiety cost the world economy approximately a trillion dollars annually, according to World Health Organization estimates, most of which is due to lost productivity. In other words, the WHO estimates that these two are responsible for approximately 12 billion lost working days a year or about tens of millions of years of work disappearing. Not to mention the effects of burnout, anxiety or loss of judgment and creativity from months of low-level fear.

There is also a hard copy of this bill attached. The stress response is constant, triggered by chronic anxiety, allowing it to remain on for longer than it can really handle, which can lead to a host of other issues, such as insomnia, compromised immune system, high blood pressure, more frequent headaches, and gastrointestinal problems. People don't wash their symptoms away. They bring them home and the next morning, they take them home, usually worse.

Difficulty understanding why it is needed.

The pattern I always see in both clinical practice and research is that organizations are dealing with employee anxiety as a personal issue, not as an indicator of what's going on in the workplace. The convenience is that's the framing that places the responsibility with the individual. It's also typically incorrect, however.

People looking at what's known as the “psychosocial safety climate” of an organization, that is, how much an organization really cares about workers' psychological safety, rather than physical safety, discovered something intriguing. A low psychosocial safety climate almost tripled the risk of new depressive symptoms in the employees in the workplace in a year. The other way round is also true: enhancing that climate leads to a significant reduction in job strain, depression, absenteeism and presenteeism sometimes dramatically. That is, anxiety at work is not entirely the result of individuals experiencing anxiety; it is created by, or hindered, in the nature of the work.

Here again, I remember R. Again, I think of R. The feelings of anxiety were not unique. She received little feedback on a regular basis from her manager, and he did not provide feedback when he did when she wasn't sure if she was doing well or bad. Errors discussed in group e-mails not individual discussions. There wasn't a way to seek assistance without it seeming as though she was doing less than her best on her performance evaluation. All that isn't captured in a "how do you feel today?" stress survey! But everything was subtly creating her unease, line-by-line through some furtive e-mail.

Team effect - not just the individual effect

When workplace anxiety remains untreated, it's not just a matter of it not staying on one desk. Worried workers over-check their work, don't offer suggestions during meetings and put off choices because they're worried, they'll be incorrect and these are just a few of the ways they make teams less productive, which are difficult to identify and pinpoint with precision. The same thing happens to new hires who are put into an anxious team: They pick up the same hypervigilance in just a few months. In addition to the loss of a person, the company also loses months of institutional knowledge, the cost of hiring and training a replacement costs that vary but have been found to have increased significantly in the past few years, as workplace mental health has deteriorated.

What really works and what doesn't

Fortunately (if there is any), this is not a mystery to be unravelled. Based on WHO's own research, for every dollar spent treating and preventing anxiety and depression there is a fourfold return in health and productivity. That's a pretty good business return but most companies continue to spend too much cleaning up the mess of the anxiety at their workplace than they did to prevent it in the first place.

There is little that seems to make a significant difference based on what I have seen work in practice:

Train managers, NOT HR.  

Direct managers have been found to have the biggest impact on employee wellbeing at work, more often than not, than their salary and company policy. A manager who shows up on a regular basis, provides feedback for the individual in private and in real time, and does not call them out on it if the concern is raised does more to reduce anxiety than any wellness app!

Normalise the naming of the problem as soon as possible.  

Untreated anxiety for months is far more difficult to deal with as opposed to the first few weeks. Which is why it's important to create micro-opportunities for staff to say "I'm having trouble" without getting in trouble for it later.

Eliminate ambiguity not mood!  

There's a lot of stress at work and it's not necessarily due to workload. It's the uncertainty stuff: unclear expectations, mixed up feedback, behind the scenes decisions. Any one wellness program won't have as much ongoing positive effect as eliminating that uncertainty.

Don't consider presenteeism a victory, it's a red flag!  

When a person never takes a day off and never goes to sleep, it doesn't necessarily mean that the person is dedicated. Occasionally it is someone who is too nervous to say that they need sleep!

The real cost

It's not the absence of employees, the expense of their health care or even the cost of turnover that's the most expensive component of workplace anxiety. It's the years of great ideas that never get voiced that we have to deal with, as well as the many things that will be wrong that will go undetected until too late because someone was too hasty to expose them. And it's the departure of good employees because they simply can't keep up the pretence of being great. Growing up, R. would often find herself overwhelmed by the tasks and responsibilities of her job, but no one ever noticed that she was doing them. It's not your fault. That is an organisational expenditure, one which is right under our noses.

If workplace anxiety is affecting your team, meaningful support can start with understanding what's creating it. Connect with us to explore your next step.
Blog & news

Discover valuable resources